How to Negotiate a Settlement Agreement: Jane Ellis’ Tips for Employees

Negotiating a Settlement Agreement UK

Don’t Sign Too Soon: How to Negotiate a Settlement Agreement You’re Happy With

Reaching the point of a settlement agreement can feel like you have no choice but to accept what you are given. The choices you make today can protect your money, your reputation and how you feel moving forward. 

 

If you are an employee, you might feel frustrated or disappointed after years of loyalty and hard work. You may worry that pushing for a better offer will rock the boat or lead to more stress. It is normal to wonder if you are settling for less than you deserve. 

 

The truth is, negotiating does not have to mean conflict. Handled calmly and clearly, it is your chance to agree on a fair outcome that protects your interests, avoids surprises later and allows everyone to move on with confidence. 

 

Jane Ellis, our trusted employment law specialist, has guided hundreds of people through settlement agreement negotiations. She knows the pitfalls, the worries on both sides and the practical steps that help people feel protected and certain they have done the right thing. 

 

This guide brings together Jane’s most practical negotiation tips for employees. You will learn what you can realistically ask for, how to handle tough conversations, and how to protect your position while keeping the process fair and professional. 

 

Take a breath. Take your time. And do not sign until you are sure you are happy with what is in front of you. 

Person with personal injury claim

Settlement Agreement Tips: Check Offer First

What to Check Before You Sign a Settlement Agreement

Before you dive into how to negotiate, it is worth making sure you understand exactly what a settlement agreement means for you. If you are still working out what you are signing and what rights it affects, take a few minutes to read our clear step-by-step guide first: 

 

Read: [Settlement Agreements Explained: What to Check Before You Sign or Offer] 

 

It will help you feel certain about what you are agreeing to, so you can come back here ready to understand how to negotiate better terms. 

Arrange To Speak With Our Employment Specialist

Jane Ellis - Settlement Agreement Solicitor

Arrange To Speak With Our Employment Law Solicitor

Jane has particular expertise in negotiating and advising on Settlement Agreements. Since qualifying as a Solicitor in 1991 Jane has developed a depth of experience in handling the termination of employment of senior executives and directors whether acting for the employer or the employee.


Jane specialises in all areas of Employment Law mainly acting for employees and Senior Executives. She has particular expertise in the rail and automotive sectors but has wide experience in many industry sectors.

Arrange A Call With Jane
Customer review about our employment law solicitor

Jane restored our faith in mankind. She truly is one of life’s angels and helped guide our ship to a safe shore with success. The money will help provide short term security, rest and recovery and we can assess where we go from here as a family. 


We have been blessed to have Jane on our side as an expert and cannot be more grateful. Jane has very quickly become more than our solicitor and a true friend indeed.

Settlement Agreement Negotiation Tips for Employees

How to Secure a Fair Deal When Receiving Your Settlement Agreement 

Being asked to accept a settlement agreement can feel like you have no real choice. Especially if you feel let down by an employer you gave so much to. It is normal to worry that pushing back could cost you the offer altogether. 

 

But this is not just about signing a piece of paper. This is your chance to protect what you have worked for, secure your financial future, and move on with your head held high. 

 

You do not have to do this alone. 

 

Jane Ellis, our trusted employment law specialist, has helped hundreds of employees negotiate fairer packages, better references and clearer terms - always with calm, straight-talking advice that helps you stand your ground with confidence. 

 

Her practical, realistic steps will help you see what you can ask for, when to speak up and how to protect your position: 

Step 1: Know You Can Negotiate a Settlement Agreement

Too many people sign too soon because they feel they have no choice. Employers expect you to ask questions and discuss the draft. 

 

If you skip this step: 

  • You might miss out on extra money you deserve
  • You could agree to restrictions that limit your next job 
  • You may feel regret once it is too late to make changes 

 

Before you agree: 

  • Read every line slowly 
  • Write down what feels unfair or unclear
  • Get legal advice on how to raise your questions calmly

Jane will guide you on what is reasonable to push for so you do not feel like you are asking for too much. 

Step 2: How to Decide What to Negotiate in a Settlement Agreement

Negotiation is not just about the money. Small details can have a big impact on your next job or your peace of mind. 

 

Ask yourself: 

  • Is there a fair reference to help you move on? 
  • Does it explain your departure clearly so your reputation is protected? 
  • Do you have a sensible timeframe to plan your exit? 
  • Are you clear about any limits on who you can work for next?  

If you miss these: 

  • You might struggle to get hired again 
  • You could find yourself facing unexpected restrictions later 

Jane helps you make a practical list so you know exactly what is worth discussing. 

Step 3: How to Know What is Realistic to Ask For in a Settlement Agreement

One of the biggest fears is pushing too hard and losing the offer. But you also do not want to accept less than you deserve. 

 

Think carefully: 

  •  Would a tribunal award you more than what is on the table? 
  • Does the offer cover all unpaid wages, holiday pay and any bonuses? 
  • Is it fair for your years of service? 

 

If you do not check: 

  • You could walk away with less than you are owed 

Jane uses her experience to help you compare your offer to what you could realistically get elsewhere so you can back up your requests with facts. 


Step 4: How to Time and Frame Your Settlement Agreement Negotiation

Good timing and a calm approach can make all the difference. Raising issues too soon or too forcefully can close the door to fair negotiation. 

 

Before you respond: 

  • Give yourself time to process the offer
  • Plan what really matters to you
  • Stay calm and professional so you are heard and respected 

 Jane will help you plan what to say and when so your questions get proper answers. 

Step 5: Why You Should Not Negotiate a Settlement Agreement Alone

Trying to handle this alone when you feel stressed or angry can cloud your judgement. Many people accept the first offer just to get it over with but regret it later. 

 

You do not have to do this by yourself:

  • Jane has guided hundreds of people through these difficult conversations 
  • She knows when to push and when to settle 
  • She will help you feel prepared so you protect your future and your peace of mind  

Before you sign anything, make sure you feel clear, protected and ready to move on. 

Person concerned over Settlement Agreement claim

Negotiating Settlement Agreements FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions About Negotiating a Settlement Agreement

When you reach the point of negotiating a settlement agreement, you deserve more than vague advice. These are real questions people search for when they feel anxious about what is fair, what they can ask for and how to avoid costly mistakes. 

 

Here is what Jane Ellis, our trusted employment law specialist, wants you to know so you feel clear, confident and protected. 

  • Can I Ask for More Money in a Settlement Agreement?

    Yes. Many people think the first offer is final but it rarely is. A settlement agreement is a negotiation by nature, not just a legal formality to tick off. If the compensation does not reflect what you are giving up, such as your right to bring future claims, you have every right to ask for more. 

     

    It helps to keep your request realistic and backed up with facts. For example, you can compare the offer with what a tribunal might award, the length of your service, any unpaid wages or bonuses, and the risks and costs your employer avoids by settling now. 

     

    Jane has helped hundreds of people work out what is fair and what is worth negotiating so you do not feel like you are pushing too far or leaving money behind. She makes sure you do not feel forced to accept less than you deserve. 

  • What Happens If My Employer Refuses to Negotiate My Settlement Agreement?

    If your employer says no to changes, you are not automatically stuck with a bad deal. You are under no obligation to sign if you do not feel the offer is fair. You still have the legal right to pursue your claim through an employment tribunal if you choose to walk away. 

     

    It is normal to feel worried about the consequences of pushing back but a respectful counteroffer rarely burns bridges if it is handled calmly. Jane will help you compare the offer to your likely tribunal outcome, talk through your best alternatives and make sure you do not feel cornered into a decision that leaves you worse off. 

  • How Long Does It Take to Negotiate a Settlement Agreement?

    Some settlement agreement negotiations wrap up within a few days while others take a few weeks depending on the complexity and how open both sides are to discussion. Trying to push for a deal overnight can lead to missed details, unfair terms or costly misunderstandings. 

     

    It is always worth taking a bit more time to get every word right, especially when it shapes your future income and rights. Jane helps people plan realistic timelines, avoid unnecessary delays and stay calm when they feel pressured to sign too fast. 

  • Can I Change My Mind After Starting Settlement Agreement Negotiations?

    Yes, you can. Many people think that once they start talking they have to accept the final offer but you are not legally bound until you have signed and received independent legal advice. If you feel the terms are unfair or something crucial has not been covered you have every right to pause or walk away. 

     

    Jane helps her clients make sense of when to keep talking, when to stand firm and when to step back. She gives you the facts you need so you do not regret signing something you are not comfortable with. 

  • How Much More Should I Ask for in a Settlement Agreement?

    There is no one-size-fits-all figure for how much more to ask for. The right number depends on what you might get if your claim went to tribunal, how much risk your employer wants to avoid, your length of service and any extra costs that could be saved by settling now. 

     

    A fair negotiation looks at what is realistic, not just what you hope for. Jane will help you check every detail, from lost wages to future earnings impact, so you can ask for an amount that feels fair and is backed up with facts, not just emotion. This is where her experience can make a real difference. 

  • Can a Settlement Agreement Be Rejected After Negotiation?

    Yes. Even if you have spent time negotiating, either side can reject the final deal if it does not feel right. This is why it is so important to get realistic advice from the start so you do not waste time or sign something that does not protect you properly. 

     

    Jane always makes sure her clients know exactly where they stand and have a backup plan if an agreement is not possible. Her goal is to keep you protected and avoid any regrets later on. 

Book Settlement Agreement Call With Expert Lawyer UK

Feel Confident Before You Negotiate or Sign: Book an Introduction Call

Reaching this point means you now know more than most people ever do about how to negotiate a settlement agreement that truly protects your best interests. You know you do not have to accept the first offer in silence, sign away your rights too soon or worry that you might be asking for too much. 

 

You have seen how the right negotiation can shape your future income, your next job move and your peace of mind for years to come. But you should never have to work it out alone or feel like you are second-guessing every word. 

 

Jane Ellis, our trusted employment law specialist, has guided hundreds of employees through settlement agreement negotiations when it mattered most. She is known for turning stress and confusion into calm, clear advice that helps you get fair results without unnecessary conflict. 

 

People trust Jane because she listens, helps you sense-check what is realistic and shows you how to back up your position with facts so you never feel rushed or cornered. 

 

You deserve that peace of mind too. If you are ready to talk through your options, check your offer or simply get a second opinion on what you are giving up, Jane is ready to help. It costs nothing to have that first conversation. 

 

Arrange your free introduction call with Jane Ellis today and feel certain about what you are agreeing to. 

Arrange To Speak With Our Employment Specialist

Jane Ellis - Settlement Agreement Solicitor

Arrange To Speak With Our Employment Law Solicitor

Jane has particular expertise in negotiating and advising on Settlement Agreements. Since qualifying as a Solicitor in 1991 Jane has developed a depth of experience in handling the termination of employment of senior executives and directors whether acting for the employer or the employee.


Jane specialises in all areas of Employment Law mainly acting for employees and Senior Executives. She has particular expertise in the rail and automotive sectors but has wide experience in many industry sectors.

Arrange A Call With Jane
Customer review about our employment law solicitor

Jane restored our faith in mankind. She truly is one of life’s angels and helped guide our ship to a safe shore with success. The money will help provide short term security, rest and recovery and we can assess where we go from here as a family. 


We have been blessed to have Jane on our side as an expert and cannot be more grateful. Jane has very quickly become more than our solicitor and a true friend indeed.

READ OUR BLOG POSTS & LATEST NEWS

Discussing a Personal Injury Claim
August 29, 2025
Worried you don’t have enough evidence for a personal injury claim? Our 2025 checklist explains what counts as proof - photos, reports, medical records & more - and how Ellis Hass & Co Solicitors can help fill in the gaps.
July 31, 2025
Injured and unsure if you can claim? This expert personal injury UK guide explains who can claim, what makes a claim valid, the step-by-step process, PI claim types, and how to get clear, local No Win No Fee advice without pressure.
July 31, 2025
Not sure what you’re signing in a Settlement Agreement? Jane Ellis, trusted UK solicitor, shares what to check in your settlement agreement, what rights you give up, and how to protect your income & job prospects. Get expert legal advice before you sign.
Holiday Accident Claims: 4 Crucial Steps to Take After an Injury Abroad
April 4, 2025
As summer unfolds, many of us eagerly anticipate holidays filled with relaxation and adventure. While these moments create lasting memories, they also come with potential risks. From slip-and-fall accidents to food poisoning or injuries from water sports, unexpected incidents can quickly turn a dream getaway into a stressful experience.
Understanding Settlement Agreements: Employee Impact, Benefits and the Importance of Non-Disclosure
March 25, 2025
Navigating the end of an employment relationship can be challenging, especially when legal agreements are involved. A settlement agreement offers a structured way to resolve disputes, ensuring both parties can move forward without lengthy legal battles. This guide explores what settlement agreements are, their benefits for employees, and key considerations when signing one.
Are You Doing Enough to Stay Safe at Work? 4 Key Workplace Safety Tips
February 12, 2025
A safe and secure workplace isn’t just the responsibility of management - it’s a shared commitment among all employees. Whether you work in an office, a construction site or a warehouse, taking the right precautions can prevent serious work accidents and injuries.
Show More